Measured entry
shadcn-select
A client-side React select assembled from Radix UI primitives and shipped as copied TypeScript source rather than a packaged widget. It uses Lucide icons, a local cn helper, Tailwind utility classes, and shadcn theme tokens for the trigger, portal menu, items, labels, separators, and scroll controls.



Measured
Every value below was written by the harness on the run that produced the frames above. None of it is derived from the prose.
| Build | OK |
|---|---|
| Mount | OK |
| Console errors | 0 |
| Uncaught page errors | 0 |
| Horizontal overflow | clean at 375, 768, 1440 |
| Axe critical | 1 |
| Axe serious | 0 |
| Axe moderate | 0 |
| Axe minor | 0 |
| Gzip marginal | 44.6 KB (109.2 KB build, 64.6 KB baseline) |
| Bare mode | FAIL |
| Provider required | NO |
| Demo used | written from the component source API |
What the harness recorded
BARE BUILD
✗ Build failed in 1.78s error during build: [vite:load-fallback] Could not load <sandbox>/src/lib/utils (imported by src/cut/components/ui/select.tsx): ENOENT: no such file or directory, open '<sandbox>/src/lib/utils'
Verdict
A solid fit for an existing shadcn codebase, with useful composition and stable mounting across the tested layouts. It needs a shadcn-style setup and should not ship until the trigger has an explicit accessible name.
Use it if
- You already use the shadcn styling conventions and want an editable Radix-based select.
- You need grouped options, labels, separators, or scroll controls in a consistent menu.
- You want keyboard and portal behavior supplied by Radix while retaining control of the source.
Skip it if
- You need a drop-in package that works without Tailwind theme tokens and a local utility helper.
- You want a native select for simple forms, browser autofill, or minimal client-side code.
- You cannot remediate the unnamed trigger reported by the accessibility check before release.
Install
| Declared dependencies | radix-ui |
|---|---|
| Missing on install | none |
| Bare install | fails once the shadcn-style helpers are removed, so it needs that setup |
| Provider | no provider required in the harness |
In a non-shadcn project, add Radix UI and Lucide React, provide the cn class-merging helper, configure Tailwind with the referenced theme tokens and state animations, preserve client-component support, and give each trigger an accessible label.
Source and credit
This page is a review, not a copy. The component source lives with its author and this site does not republish it. Read the license before you use anything.
Author repository
github.com/shadcn-ui/uiAlternatives
Other published entries for the select pattern, ordered by what they measured: mounts first, then clean axe scans, then bare-mode passes, then the smaller bundle.
- hextaui-native-selectminimal-flat
- Renders
- YES
- A11y
- 0
- Gzip
- 30.6KB
- Bare
- fail
- Prov
- NO
- 8bitcn-difficulty-selectskeuomorphism
- Renders
- YES
- A11y
- 0
- Gzip
- 32.7KB
- Bare
- fail
- Prov
- NO
- hextaui-checkboxminimal-flat
- Renders
- YES
- A11y
- 0
- Gzip
- 35.8KB
- Bare
- fail
- Prov
- NO
- hextaui-radio-groupminimal-flat
- Renders
- YES
- A11y
- 0
- Gzip
- 40.3KB
- Bare
- fail
- Prov
- NO
- ruixen-tag-cloud-selectunclassified
- Renders
- YES
- A11y
- 0
- Gzip
- 58.8KB
- Bare
- fail
- Prov
- NO
- tripled-animated-select-shadcnuiminimal-flat
- Renders
- YES
- A11y
- 0
- Gzip
- 60.4KB
- Bare
- fail
- Prov
- NO